Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Assam Violence

Violence was just waiting to happen in Assam. It happened now; it could be anytime. The violence had its wake that extended to Mumbai and there has been reported exodus of all North-Easterners from Hyderabad which was heretofore a great place for them to work and to integrate into this country where prejudices against them run high. A Tibetan has been stabbed in Mysore which may even be the consequence of the same communal hatred that began to rise from the otherwise quiet Assam.

The country has been divided on religious and caste lines due to its policies of differentiating between them for all discourse in the Parliament, legislatures and public domain, fossilising the division through unending lists, schedule if you like of a great variety. The division is between the followers of different religions such as the Hindus (which is wrongly used by the government to cover many non-Hindus such as Jains), Muslims, Sikhs, Christians etc. Within them they have sectarian divide, not spurred in small measure by the reservation policies and religious bigotry which together form the most lethal social poison. The polls happen on the basis pf caste and religion. Gangs of Wasseypur has shown how even the Muslims known for their solidarity in all matters of state are divided. There are Syeds, julahas, kasais, and I do not how many others. Hindus of course are the most divided of all. The castes were originally defined according to the occupation of different social groups and thus their was division of labour that resulted in ensuring all people could earn their livelihood without encroaching the specific terrain of each other. This became a burden instead of a boon due to the persecution of the weaker by the powerful and the rich of India for generations.

One must stop here and ask whether the mentality of the Indian of exploiting the weak is merely caste based, or is it all pervading. I think the latter is true. The average Indian tends to exploit the weaker and suppress the weak through his economic, political or brute power. burgeoning numbers of rapes are but a small indicator that brings the extreme of this malaise of the Indian on shameful display. But you will see this even starting from a petty Constable to the Minister and their behaviour towards a Rickshaw puller or a beggar to the IAS secretary in the ministry. The streak of this malicious mentality is all pervading and starkly visible at all times. What is happening to our temper? What makes us so impatient and tense? fear of each other? Fear of losing something? Unsafety we feel? Arrogance that is ingrained in us from childhood without any sense of fairness? Perhaps all of it.

But I want to write about the riots. And I have gone to the lengthy explanation and cursory exploration of the divide in Indian society that leads to the riots. the division breeds competitiveness, often unfair, which in turn leads to exploitation and usurpation by the powerful groups whether they are the so called 'minorities' or otherwise, and then finally frustrations, jealousies and lastly the violence encouraged by the desire to grab what one can't get by fair effort. This is also at the root of Assam violence. It will be found at the root of violence almost anywhere. The false sense of usurpation by Jews trumpeted by Hitler led to the WW II and to holocaust. The story is the same everywhere. The migrants from Bangladesh have flooded not only Assam but the entire country. It is believed that around Mrs. Gandhi's declaration of war on East Pakistan there were about 10 million Chakma rebels that crossed into India. Where have they gone? And during all theses years more Bangladeshis have been coming into India and vanishing, working as labour, household help or whatever all across the country using not infrequently Hindu names and claiming to be Bengalis or East Biharis. I suspect that in Ghaziabad there were plenty of them before the UP Police built pressure on them during Mayawati's regime. On one hand it is hard to understand why Indian Muslims do not oppose them and why consecutive governments have done nothing to send them back to Bangladesh. The political parties want their votes, but what about India Muslims? The foreigners come and take their jobs too among those of others. And no Muslim country would allow the refugee Muslims to come and settle in large numbers, not Saudi Arabia even which is the topmost seat of Islam. This means no country brooks any incomers irrespective of their religion. Our boundaries are our boundaries and we have got them to live within and to survive or thrive on what nature gives us within those boundaries and what we can make of it.

Our intolerance is at all time high and it is appalling that today we are discussing cartoons in text books, simple jokes that have been humour without malice, ordinary caste references all inflame us no end. And we have demonstrations, acrimony, violence - anything that is far from civility at the bat of an eyelid.

Assam violence happened because the demography changed there. the infiltrators are usurping the scarce resources of the Bodos and this is not a situation that can be accepted for long by any community that has lived there for ever and has nowhere else to go.

There are rumours that the strife is between the Budhhists and Muslims in that area. I prefer to think it is between the owners of the place and the infiltrators. If we eventually did find that that there were religious undertones to the strife, indeed this will throw open the bigger question for future of the nation. The three aggressively converting religious active in India are Buddhism, Christianity and Islam in the same order. It would seem that Hindus would become a minority ceding a large chunk to these religions, being the sole donors. This major demographic change will bring about unprecedented strife as a failing group will make its last ditch, desperate attempts to survive. Things can not be stopped but we should not underestimate or brush aside the forebodings of utter chaos that may one day grip the country. We must initiate steps now to avoid the possible strife that will inevitably occur if foreigners of any religion, caste, nationality or identity will continue to infest our land.

Monday, March 1, 2010

Where are we going?

India is a democracy wherein a huge number of parliamentarians or legislators are known to have criminal background or connections. One may say that crime is after all their 'private' life. The same can be said of a lot of graft and sleeze that goes on in high places but no one ever wants to investigate and put an end to.

China is our second most important national obsession at the moment, next only to; no not cricket, Pakistan. On the television I believe that the most spoken single word theses days is Pakistan followed by perhaps 'Atank...'.

We hear all the time about the threat from Pakistan and how it is not acting against terrorists working across our borders from its soil. Do we ever ask what WE are doing about the terrorists here and the providers of shelter and the sleeping cells. Digvijay Singh would say that is an atrocity against Muslims. But these are not only Muslims and the law should be equally tough and proactive irrespective of their religious affiliation. Rather, the religious affiliation, minority tag or whatever other badge of Maulana, Sant or Pandit should not provide the subverters of India licence.

The United States has already delivered punishment to Headley for crimes including terrorism (India) and we are still nowhere near doing anything about Kasab, much less hanging Afzal Guru of the parliament attack case. India is indeed Mahaan!

Chinese are making incursions into our terrirtory at will. We are silently bearing it. We have no wherewithal or the will to fight a mighty enemy. Our foreign policy is an abject failure. The country is in disarray which is only thinly camouflaged by the recent economic glitter and deceptive growth rate data. The communal and caste rivalries and the suspicion amongst them are at an unprecedented level, mutual tolerance amongst various parts of society is at an all time low, sense of humour has been replaced by caution even in a joke, honesty has been thrown away for political correctness - we are sitting on a veritable tinder box. In the name of elimination of the caste divide we have widened it to a point where reconnection is now impossible.

Why is the country going where it is? If you see carefully at out parliament and legislatures you would be appalled at the total absence of discussion and healthy argument on any matter of national security, finance, education and allocation of revenue. The discussion and discourse is mainly about caste, reservations, provisions for pilgrimages, minorities, dalits and  so on. Indeed all these need attention but won't for long if the state itself fails, and risks its very existence.

Is India safe?

India is a democracy that is lionised by the whole 'free' world as the largest 'functioning' democracy. There is of course the moot question whether the 'free' world is really free. But that is another topic.

India is being seen as a major emerging market and the interest of the west is very much focused on the possible economic success of this behemoth. The big IF  in 'If India becomes economically powerful' is the problem. We notice that India has failed to sell itself to the west as a strong ally and the military interests of the US continue to weigh heavily in favour of Pakistan. India's economic growth has not yet reached the magic triple point where the interests of the west, India and world peace might converge.

China is far more successful than India on the three fronts; economic, military and world standing. There are no moralities in international politics, only self centered moves. China far outweighs India. Actually even Pakistan is far more successful in selling itself to the world community; first - in the old times as a great miltary ally and base for the US/ Allieds against the Iron and Bamboo curtain nations, second - as the rogue state that MUST be nurtured so it does not fall apart lest any last vestiges of organisation in this part of the world vanish, third - as the merchant of terror playing a hapless victim of it itself and fourth, in the context of South Asia - as the right ally to India's traditional adversary China; following the old maxim of an enemy's enemy being a friend. India has miserably failed to place itself in the position of a good neighbour and influencer. Even Nepal and Bangladesh, India's old military proctorate of the yore and the child of India's toil to help it be born respectively are bitter critics of India and are ever willing to allow anti-Indian activities on their soils. I feel that they are certainly much closer to China than to India.

I think it calls for serious introspection on the part of Indian leadership. Why is it that we always fail to convince others? Are we not seen as sincere by the world? Could it be that our policy interlocuters are unable to call a spade a spade for the sake of political correctness or crass vote bank politics at home? Are we sermonising others to the point of causing an affront? Are we inept in stating our point and inarticulate in convincing the world of our problems? Are we trying to impress the world with our philosophical, large hearted world view instead of beeing seen as winners, driving hard bargains even if they are self-centered? Or, is it all of it?

By what authority can we call Pakistan a failed state when huge tracts of our territory are under the control of Naxals and assorted non-government forces? All the big threats of direct action made by Chidambaram some months ago are still just that - empty threats. We are the proverbial soft state where the killer of Inspector Sharma of Batla House episode admits to have shot him, may be with even a bit of pride, but Digvijay Singh sees every investigation as atrocity on a particular community. Does India have a chance?

Hafiz saeed was shouting hoarse on the streets of Lahore two weeks back exhorting people to invade India and to fight for their 'Brethren' on this side. The question is how come not a single Muslim opinion builder (barring the exceptions like M.J. Akbar and Arif Mohammad Khan) never tells these people that Indian Muslims are not their brethren but enemies if they as much as think of harming India, far from invade it? Why are the likes of Javed Akhtar, Shabana Azmi, Dilip Kumar, Shah Rukh Khan, Nawab of Pataudi and his son, Mohd. Azam Khan and Mahesh Bhatt sitting in mysterious silence while many of them shout at the top of their voices when Pakistani players are not bought in an auction (SRK should have bought but didn't) or Maqbool Fida has to go in self-exile. Why don't the Indian Muslim leaders tell pakistan that it would be punished for casting an evil eye on India? I know why. When the late Firoze Khan spoke for India in Pakistan and risked his life and limb, people like them and their cronies like Rajeev Shukla and Mahesh Bhatt were trying to fault Firoze Khan, or busy distancing themselves from the episode. So a devoted Indian Muslim may be afraid of his Hindu counterparts - citizens like these and Digvijay and a plethora of others.

Time to think for all Indians. Let all of us unite against the enemy. If religion were the reason for this kind of dangerous political correctness, let me remind the pseudos that if it were so the Middle East would be one country.

Sunday, February 14, 2010

What Revenge?

The Times of India carried an article by Yamini Lohia expressing unrestrained glee over the Youth Congress smearing Sri Ram Sene head Pramod Muthalik's face in Managalore and going on to say that she would wish she could personally perpetrate this act of violence.


Violence is not only in causing physical hurt. It can be at many levels. Even silence can be a kind of violence. Another issue of TOI carried a story that a High Court held that in a marriage silence could tantamount to cruelty. Ms. Lohia feels that there is a justification for violence by groups with whose ideology she agrees and calls it sweet revenge. There is an unending discussion on the moral policing in the country but the advocates of freedom are always mysteriously silent when there is a fatwa in Kashmir for headscarves or for wearing Burqas. There is no discussion if Katrina Kaif is disallowed entry to a Dargah for being in an inappropriate dress. There is repeated discussion on the practices in Hindu temples including Sabrimala and Puri but nobody dares to speak about the practices and methods of their enforcement in other religions, the way they are practised in India. Is it not a bit strange?


There is no discussion if women are not allowed in certain places of worship belonging to other religions but there is much hue and cry on Sabrimala. Mahesh Bhatt and people of his ilk shout hoarse when somebody vandalises Hussains grotto in Ahmedabad in the name of freedom of art but they have nothing to say about the fatwas routinely issued on the lives of Salman Rushdie or the Danish painter, Taslima Nasreen and others. Is there something amiss? Is there a secret fear amongst the pseudo secularists that there antics won't work with Muslims but they have tested Hindus again and again and they know that in that case they can get away with whatever they like.


Let us look dispassionately at other things. The English speaking media people, editorial contributors, people like Jug Suraiya, Mahesh Bhatt and sundry cranks flaunt Hindu bashing like a medal. But they never fail to swear by Indian culture. I wonder if that is a kind of metaphor for Hindu culture. If Hindu culture is not about modesty (if with much less restrictions than in Islam), if it is not about vegetarianism, if it is not about Vedic religions and their offshoots and sub-cultures, if it is not about a certain code of conduct and set of boundaries in public and private behaviours (Maryadas), what is it about? And if these guardians of secularism and freedom are so worried about saying 'OM' or 'Jai Ram ji' in private being saffron, not withstanding the loudspeakers on mosques broadcasting Azaan, how come they don't realise the hurt the 'Indian Culture' is causing to minorities and to Indian Muslims in particular by singing Ganesh Vandanas, lighting lamps, chanting 'Tam so ma Jyotirgamaya', garlanding and vermilion marking foreheads of visitors and taking their Aratis and all the ceremonies that surround almost any and all Indian functions, most of them functions of a secular government, and the singing of Vande Mataram. Why have they not tried to stop it all? Is it fair? Before the British came Hindus were not ruling this land mass. I have the feeling that a lot of Muslims and especially those associated with Jamiat and other similar organisations, and those that chose to leave India at partition strongly felt betrayed by the British, as in their opinion the British took the rule from them and handed it over to Hindus. They are unable of course, to differentiate between a democracy and a theocracy of Hindus. But on a very real plane, they may not be that wrong, at least as far as the rule having been snatched away from them and handed over to whoever else. From their perspective there is also the downside that if we look at the number of years it took to convert a large part of Hindu population to other religions was not much - just four centuries or so. And the current rate of conversion is also quite high. If the British were not in India, arguably Hindus would have been a small minority in India by the middle of 20th century when the British left, as they became in Kashmir and probably in Kerala, Ladakh region and possibly some north eastern states.


Hindus have bragged about their tolerance for centuries now. I wonder if it is the smokescreen to hide their cowardice. M.J. Akbar is to my mind the most rational and straight thinking political thinker and commentator and he famously lionised Hindu tolerance for peaceful life of Muslims and small minorities in India in a debate I happened to watch on television. It was very charitable of him but I suspect it is probably not true. Hindus were defeated again and again by foreign conquerors and the vanquished may or may not be tolerant - it does not matter.

Friday, July 17, 2009

Religious Symbols, Relics and Statues with Public Funds - Wonders of a Secular State

Mr. Rahul Gandhi said that UP had all the place for statues but none for development and power. Mr. Gandhi is right. Only he somehow sees a difference between what Congress is doing in the whole country and what Mayawati is doing in UP. All new projects, roads, parks, colonies, airports, institutions etc. get only the Gandhi family names. I see no difference. Both Gandhi dynasty and Ms. Mayawati are busy sith self aggrandisement at the cost of the nation and the taxpayer. Mayaji has less time so she has to do it faster and more aggressively. The sycophancy and narcissism are two big gifts to the nation from Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. What is the wonder then if every neta wants something in his or her name at the cost of national exchequer?What Gandhi is missing is that Ms. Mayawati's expenditure is not on just 'Statues' She is building Bauddha Vihars and is promoting a particular religion with Government funds. Maybe he can't see that because his sister is a staunch Budhist as well. So much for secularism! How brazenly public funds are being channelised for promotion of Buddhism is appalling. And, where are the people? What about RSS, VHP, BJP and the so called Sangh parivar? And the Shankaracharyas?
No PILs? No comments in the papers. Nothing on the electronic media?

Monday, July 13, 2009

The Indian 'Pseudo Secularist's' Convenient Hindu Ambiguity

Comment sent to TOI (Unlikely to be printed being politically incorrect) on July 13, 2009 on news item that Salman Khurshid thinks in the absence of a legal framework to force the private sector to give jobs to minorities, they should come forward to do so on their own.

The Government should declare the real figures of the number of Muslim, Jains, Sikhs, Christians, Atheists, Agnostics, Parsis and Buddhists.

I estimate that the Buddhists are not less than 12% of the population. The illegal Bangladeshi immigrants that were estimated at 10,000,000 in 1975 should now be around 3 crores by way of natural growth and multiplication. Most unfortunately, lately the Jains have begun to claim that they are not 'Hindus' and this has been recognised by the law. The same applies to 'Sikhs'. So who are the Hindus that are claimed to be 80% of the population? The numbers just don't add up and the non-Muslims, non-Christians and non-Sikhs, Atheists and Agnostics are not the only non-Hindus. If Hindus mean 'Vedists' inclusive of all their sects, sub-sects and affiliations only, they may not be more than 40% of the population. That means they may at best be the largest single religious group but are certainly not a 'majority'. And in any country population groups of say 20 to 25% such as the Muslims and the Jains can't be construed as really a 'Minority'.

On the other hand, the truth is that 'Hindu' is a word that was coined by the people west of the Indus which was 'Sindhu' at that time. As many races from the Middle East pronounced 'Sa' as 'Ha', Sindhu became Hindu. So all people on this land mass were Hindus to the marauding Iranians, Afghans, Turks etc. Actually Hindu is a signifier of a culture that existed then in the northern part of the subcontinent. So it actually is a cultural Umbrella that covered all religious sects in the region. This is further borne out by the great cultural synthesis and consequent similarities amongst all communities from before the invaders, mostly Muslim began to visit here for plunder. It is therefore sad that all the religionists such as Jains, Sikhs etc. are distancing themselves from 'Hindu' whereas they probably only want to differentiate themselves religiously from the Vedists or Sanatan Dharmis or Arya Samajis, rather than to pretend to belong to some alien cultures. This chasm however is set only to grow wider in the future, given the leadership of various clergy and socio-political vested interests of different groups. So be it. But that is then an urgent reason to clarify that all these people are different and are definitely not Hindus. That is mainly because they do not any more wish to identify themselves in this wider cultural manner but in narrower religios groupings, even refusing to accept a common root.

I believe therefore that it is time we lift the shroud of convenient ambiguity from the definition of 'Hindu' before the nation discusses the Hindu and minority issues any further.

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Legal Reforms the Country Needs Urgently

India has a pendency of 30 million cases. Everyone talks about it and everyone keeps mouthing the cliché 'Justice delayed is justice denied'. Hardly anyone goes beyond this remark accompanied by some noises that may sound appropriate. Almost no one suggests any remedy. I am not a legal expert. But I suppose the legal experts are the real reason why there can not be any reforms. I would like to touch upon only the concerns of people and what I think might benefit the country and the public, huge amount of national time that eats into our productivity and tons of money that are lost on the non-dispensation of justice.

The country gave up the system of Jury and speedy justice. At one time there were also Honorary Magistrates that no longer exist. I wonder whether the judiciary should think of re-introducing these systems at low cost. I am sure the legal experts have a huge number of reasons to argue against the system that may range from the inexperience in the art or the science of 'Judgement' to the clear possibility of corruption and partisan behaviour. The question is whether is it not an honest truth that these maladies afflict the jurisprudence in the form we practice it now as well. In the present system there is also a great deal of impunity implied in the appointments of theses civil servants which may make them less accountable. In the old system and the American model this impunity may be less. Removal of the honorary judges and Jury may be a lot easier. I am not sure Honour is a highly cherished value in our system.

In the appointment of judges we should institute greater transparency. There should be greater accountability. The performance of the Judges must be assessed by harshest of standards because these men of law wield huge power over the fates of the people. Their ability to take decisions, their analytical capability, honesty, value system etc. must be checked thoroughly before inducting them into judiciary. For this rigorous psychological tests including aptitude and personality tests must be instituted. Only the best of the men should be entrusted with people's fates and often, their careers and even lives. I doubt most judges will pass these tests. Correspondingly the punishments for the erring judges should also be harsher as no one can fathom the damage they may have caused to hundreds of people through their ineptness or sheer malpractice.

For crimes against the nation the legal process should be made faster and straight forward. What proof and evidence does the nation need against say, Afzal Guru or Ajmal Kasab? Hours of television feeds, openly conducted attacks and arrests from the scenes of commitment of these heinous crimes demand further proof? Are we not out of our minds to be wasting the nation's money and time on extended trials that may merely give greater publicity to the criminals and make the state seem soft. The criminals may even become, over time, heroes or role models for many youngsters. What are we hoping to achieve? What justice can we dispense through this waste of time? What will change? What is not known and public knowledge? And, if we must maintain the pretence of a just society is one single hearing and summary trial not enough? Will their repeated exposure not help feed religious fanaticism of weak minded amongst certain communities and create more of the Afzal Gurus and the Kasabs, even from within the country. This is one reform that we need yesterday!

Another reform we need very badly is the system of appeals. I think this would be the most important one and will be the only solution to the ever increasing queue of cases pending in India courts, now exceeding 30 million. My idea is that in the cases decided by the lower courts, conciliation courts etc. the right to appeal should be limited. It should not be that a party loses a case and loses or wins in the next court and loses again and so on and the feuding parties may go on fighting for the whole life and even into next generations.

Their should be fast track courts with the number of dates being given limited to say 5, so that the parties are forced to attend the hearings and not just keep sending their excuses or advocates to ask for fresh dates. The time within which these hearings would be held should also be limited to say six to nine months.

The judges prolonging the decisions and leaving the pendency during their tenure should be assessed for performance on the basis of these failures.

They should not be allowed to forward or recommend the cases to higher courts as far as possible. There should be admitted no representation in a higher court unless there is additional and substantive information or evidence and not just the twists and interpretations of laws. Let us say such a chance should be limited just to one court and the next higher, and then it should end. In the biggest cases where there may be question of life imprisonment, capital punishment or huge sums of money that may impact national interests only a third appeal should be allowed. But in all cases, and in all courts, there should be a limit on the number of hearings with also a limit on the time within which these hearings must be completed. The judges failing to perform should be demoted or punished in some way as the law may allow.

In order that these methods will be extremely effective the judiciary needs to tighten its own system starting from recruitment through to a judge’s rise to the highest position in the judiciary. The selection should, in addition to including personality and aptitude tests, investigate the persons’ background to ensure to the extent possible their being above board. And then, there should be stringent punishments for the erring judges. As stated earlier, in addition, there should be separate and tougher laws to judge the judges.

The lawyers should be investigated for their connections with judges and their methods as it is often suspected that many work as brokers. This may or may not be true so there should be a close watch on the entire legal system so as to ensure that no one misuses powers, connections, graft etc. to scuttle the process of justice and effectively have the justice denied to hapless seekers of it.